Current:Home > MyAlabama lawmakers advance legislation to protect IVF providers after frozen embryo ruling-InfoLens
Alabama lawmakers advance legislation to protect IVF providers after frozen embryo ruling
View Date:2024-12-23 16:45:22
MONTGOMERY, Ala. (AP) — Alabama lawmakers facing public pressure to restart in vitro fertilization services in the state advanced legislation to shield providers from the fallout of a court ruling that equated frozen embryos to children.
Committees in the state Senate and House on Tuesday approved identical bills that would protect providers from lawsuits and criminal prosecution for the “damage or death of an embryo” during IVF services. The state’s three major IVF providers paused services after the Alabama Supreme Court’s ruling last month because of the sweeping liability concerns it raised.
Lawmakers are aiming to give final approval Wednesday and send the legislation to Gov. Kay Ivey to be signed into law. They have fast-tracked the immunity legislation as a proposed solution to get clinics back open as they weigh whether additional action is needed.
“The problem we are trying to solve right now is to get those families back on track to be moving forward as they try to have children,” said Rep. Terri Collins, sponsor of one of the bills.
The court ruled that three couples who had frozen embryos destroyed in an accident at a storage facility could pursue wrongful death lawsuits for their “extrauterine children.” The ruling, treating an embryo the same as a child or gestating fetus under the wrongful death statute, raised concerns about civil liabilities for clinics.
The court decision received immediate backlash as groups across the country raised concerns about a ruling recognizing embryos as children. Patients in Alabama shared stories of upcoming embryo transfers being abruptly canceled and their paths to parenthood put in doubt.
Beth and Joshua Davis-Dillard watched as the Senate committee voted. The couple had transferred frozen embryos to Alabama after moving from New York.
“We’ve been working up to getting ready to trying again. We still have embryos from our prior cycle, which we did in New York. We transferred them here. We can’t use them. We’re on hold,” Beth Davis-Dillard said. “I’m 44, so time is limited. We don’t have unlimited time to wait. We really want to give it a try and see if we can have another baby.”
Beth David-Dillard said she felt “very helpless and very frustrated” and in a “little bit of disbelief.” She said that before they transferred the embryos to Alabama, the couple briefly discussed whether the state’s strict abortion ban or political climate could be a problem but presumed it would ultimately be fine.
“It just feels like our rights are being restricted,” she said.
The legislative proposals state that “no action, suit, or criminal prosecution for the damage to or death of an embryo shall be brought or maintained against any individual or entity when providing or receiving services related to in vitro fertilization.”
Civil lawsuits could be pursued against manufacturers of IVF-related goods, such as the nutrient-rich solutions used to grow embryos, but damages would be capped and criminal prosecution would be forbidden. Doctors have expressed concern that without some protections for manufacturers they will not be able to get the products they need to provide IVF.
Dr. Michael C. Allemand with Alabama Fertility said the legislative proposal would allow the clinic to resume IVF services by returning “us to a normal state of affairs in terms of what the liability issues are.”
He said the past weeks have been difficult on patients and staff as procedures have been postponed.
“There’s been some truly heart-wrenching conversations that have taken place,” Allemand said.
The American Society for Reproductive Medicine, a group representing IVF providers across the country, said the legislation does not go far enough. Sean Tipton, a spokesperson for the organization, said Monday that the legislation does not correct the fundamental problem, which he said is the court ruling “conflating fertilized eggs with children.”
House Democrats proposed legislation that would put in state law or the state Constitution that a human embryo outside a uterus cannot be considered an unborn child or human being under state law. Democrats argued that was the most direct way to deal with the issue. Republicans have not brought the proposals up for a vote.
State Republicans are reckoning with an IVF crisis they partly helped create with anti-abortion language added to the Alabama Constitution in 2018. The amendment, which was approved by 59% of voters, says it is state policy to recognize the “rights of unborn children.”
The phrase became the basis of the court’s ruling. At the time, supporters said it would allow the state to ban abortion if Roe v. Wade were overturned, but opponents argued it could establish “personhood” for fertilized eggs.
Collins said she doesn’t think lawmakers got it wrong with the amendment but that the wording was broad enough that it had ramifications they didn’t anticipate.
Collins, who sponsored the state’s stringent abortion ban, said she thought any law exempting embryos from legal protections might be found unconstitutional under the 2018 amendment. Changing the constitution, she said, is a longer conversation.
“It’s very divisive,” she said. “Everybody has very strong opinions on when life begins.”
Republicans are also trying to navigate tricky political waters — torn between widespread popularity and support for IVF — and conflicts within their own party. Some Republicans have unsuccessfully sought to add Louisiana-style language to ban clinics from destroying unused or unwanted embryos.
veryGood! (19227)
Related
- Stock market today: Asian shares meander, tracking Wall Street’s mixed finish as dollar surges
- Seattle police chief dismissed from top job amid discrimination, harassment lawsuits
- Reports: Texans, WR Nico Collins agree to three-year, $72.75 million extension
- Johns Hopkins team assessing nation’s bridges after deadly Baltimore collapse
- College Football Playoff ranking release: Army, Georgia lead winners and losers
- Video shows incredible nighttime rainbow form in Yosemite National Park
- Why Jana Kramer Feels “Embarrassment” Ahead of Upcoming Wedding to Allan Russell
- Ryan Reynolds Details How Anxiety Helps Him as a Dad to His and Blake Lively’s Kids
- 1 million migrants in the US rely on temporary protections that Trump could target
- Oleksandr Usyk-Tyson Fury heavyweight title rematch scheduled for Dec. 21
Ranking
- Watch: Military dad's emotional return after a year away
- Millions of older Americans still grapple with student loan debt, hindering retirement
- Explosion in downtown Youngstown, Ohio, leaves one dead and multiple injured
- Hurricane Ian destroyed his house. Still homeless, he's facing near-record summer heat.
- Quincy Jones laid to rest at private family funeral in Los Angeles
- Wheel of Fortune’s Pat Sajak Has a Must-See Response to Contestants Celebrating Incorrect Guess
- Molly Ringwald Says She Was Taken Advantage of as a Young Actress in Hollywood
- TikTok ban challenge set for September arguments
Recommendation
-
Chris Evans Shares Thoughts on Starting a Family With Wife Alba Baptista
-
'General Hospital' actor Johnny Wactor’s cause of death revealed
-
Seattle police chief dismissed from top job amid discrimination, harassment lawsuits
-
Penn Badgley Reveals Ex Blake Lively Tricked Him Into Believing Steven Tyler Was His Dad
-
Brands Our Editors Are Thankful For in 2024
-
Major leaguers praise inclusion of Negro Leagues statistics into major league records
-
7 young elephants found dead in Sri Lanka amid monsoon flooding
-
Ellen DeGeneres announces farewell tour dates, including 'special taping'